The Ironist

Differing Perspectives

From Ahura Mazda to Lucifer: Angels and the Dualism of Good and Evil

The second part of Dr. Hara’s series on angels traces how Zoroastrian dualism handed the cosmos its central plot – good versus evil. 

In the previous essay, we traced the lineage of the guardian spirit from Sumerian temple guardian to Assyrian colossal. Yet that narrative remains fundamentally incomplete. It accounts for the form of the angel – the wings, the anthropomorphic hybrid – but not the moral architecture within which angels would come to function. The guardian shedu and lamassu were powerful, certainly, but they were not combatants in a metaphysical war. That transformation came from elsewhere, from the high plateaus of Persia, where a prophet named Zoroaster (or Zarathustra) conceived of a universe fundamentally divided against itself.

Zoroastrianism is not well remembered in the West, yet its theological influence on the three great monotheistic religions cannot be overstated. It arrived at a particular historical moment – after the Persian Empire under Cyrus the Great had conquered Babylon and encountered the Jewish population in exile. The intellectual and religious exchange that followed was of profound mutual influence instead of domination. The Persians, whose empire was vastly more cosmopolitan than any that had preceded it, permitted their subject peoples to maintain their own religious practices. This tolerance, paradoxically, created the conditions for unprecedented theological synthesis.

The innovation of Zoroastrianism was radical. It posited the universe as a cosmic battlefield. Ahura Mazda, the supreme god or ‘Wise Lord’ was opposed by Ahriman, the destructive principle, the spirit of negation and death. This was not a universe governed by a single capricious deity whose moods shifted like the Tigris in flood season. Rather, it was one in which good and evil were locked in eternal struggle, each possessing real power, each commanding armies of spiritual beings. The mortal, in this cosmology, was not merely a victim of supernatural whim but a participant in this cosmic conflict, called to choose a side.

Ahura Mazda was served by the Amesha Spentas – the ‘Holy Immortals’, divine beings of tremendous power and distinct personality. They were agents and warriors of the divine realm, each presiding over an aspect of creation. Unlike the earlier Mesopotamian uttuku, which were often local and specific, these beings had a universal scope. They represented a systematized angelology almost like a hierarchy or a division of labor. When Judaic theologians, centuries later, would develop their own angelology in response to Persian influence, they would adopt this model. The archangel Michael, commanding God’s heavenly armies against Satan and his demons, carries the direct imprint of the Amesha Spentas and their conflict with the servants of Ahriman.

Yet the mirror image – the demonic principle – is equally important. Ahriman and his demonic hosts represented rebellion and the principle of entropy opposing the order established by the divine. This was a theology of stakes. The universe was not governed by arbitrary gods but human choice mattered because the outcome was genuinely uncertain.

Relief of Ahura -Mazda, from Persepolis, 5th century BC

What kind of an Ironist are You?

Take the quiz and find out.

Subscribe now

The artistic record preserves this shift with striking clarity. Consider the relief of Ahura Mazda from Persepolis, carved in the fifth century BC. The god is depicted in a pose of protective vigilance, sometimes shown protecting the sacred fire. The image radiates an intensity absent from earlier Near Eastern royal iconography. This is a god who acts, protects, and defends. The winged symbol of Ahura Mazda became one of the most enduring emblems in all of religious art, adopted and adapted by cultures from the Mediterranean to South Asia.

Against this light stood unmistakable darkness. The Assyrian demon Pazazu, carved in bronze statuettes that survive from the seventh century BC, is grotesque, demonic, winged but undeniably monstrous. Where the lamassu’s wings lifted and transcended, Pazazu’s wings suggested a violent, predatory speed. He was the demon of plague and disease, of the wind that carries contagion, the supernatural adversary that brought suffering. Pazazu was a chaotic intelligible evil.

Demon Pazazu, bronze statuette from 7th c. BC

 

Lilith, goddess of death, Sumerian relief from terracotta, 1790-1760 BC

The Sumerian goddess Lilith, whose image appears in reliefs dating to the eighteenth century BC, occupied a similar space. Originally a household spirit or demon, she gradually became associated with death and the night, a figure both feared and invoked. The evolution of her image reflects the Persian conceptual revolution. Once she was merely a local hazard, now she was death itself, opposing the forces of fertility and life.

The birth of Ahura Mazda and Ahriman, silver plaque from Luristan, 8th c. BC

Perhaps the most eloquent surviving artifact of Zoroastrian dualism is the silver plaque from Luristan, dated to the eighth century BC, depicting the birth of Ahura Mazda and Ahriman. The composition captures the theological essence – two cosmic principles emerging simultaneously, neither superior to the other in origin, each possessing inherent reality and power. This was not a world in which evil was merely the absence of good – the later Christian formulation – but rather a world in which evil was a presence, a force, an active principle requiring constant vigilance and resistance.

Mosaic from the Basilica of St. Apollinaire Nuovo, 6th century

The legacy of this vision cannot be contained within ancient history. When Jewish theologians, working in the Persian diaspora or under Persian imperial rule, began to systematize their own angelology, they borrowed the Persian framework. Michael as commander of God’s forces, Satan as the cosmic rebel, heaven and hell as opposed realms of spirit. The Christian tradition, inheriting Jewish theology and hellenizing it further, would elaborate this dualism into elaborate angelic hierarchies and demonic orders. Even Islam, arriving later into a region already saturated with these concepts, would incorporate Quranic angels and djinn into a universe fundamentally shaped by the Persian insight- that the cosmos is a stage whereupon good and evil wage an unending war.

Archangel Michael Chaining Satan, fresco from the monastery of Xeropotamou, Mt Athos,17th c
Archangel Michael Stratelatis, Civic Museum of Pisa

We inherit this vision still. When we speak of angels and demons, when we imagine a universe divided between light and darkness, we are participating in a conversation that began on the Persian high plateaus, crystallized in relief carvings and temple inscriptions, and has echoed through three millennia of Western and Near Eastern religious thought. To understand angels is to understand how the great faiths came to imagine morality and cosmic justice. The history of the angel is the history of how humanity came to see itself as a participant in the deepest struggles of existence.

The next piece will be about how these ancient guardians and cosmic warriors transformed as they encountered Greek philosophy, Jewish mysticism, and Christian theology.

Contributed by

Dr. Hara Papatheodorou

Author

  • Dr. Hara Papatheodorou was born in Athens. She studied in Montreal, Canada, and in her return to Athens, she taught Art History and the Visual Arts for a number of years at the American College of Greece (DEREE), in Athens.

    She earned her degrees in Fine Arts and Art History from McGill University, in Montreal, Canada, where she taught as well.

    Her doctorial research dealt with The Iconography of Angels in the Byzantine Art, and was accomplished at the University of Ioannina, in Greece.

    She is a practicing artist with many international exhibitions and distinctions for her art. In 1972 won the Silver Medal, in Brussels. In 1973, she was among the finalists for the Grand Prize of Rome, and she is an Associate Member of the French Artists. She has exhibited twice in The Salon of May, at the Grand Palais de Champs Elysee, in Paris.

    She has written many articles on Greek artists, and has participated in a number of conferences, referred to art history aesthetics.  Among them were Essex University in UK (2004), where she delivered a topic on Fairytales in Art: The Shock of the Marvelous, at the Piraeus University in Greece (2008) and The American Women’s Club in Athens (2008), where she delivered a topic on Women, Art and Society: The Dinner Party, dealing with the discrimination on women artists.

    She has recently retired from teaching, but she continues to lecture locally as well as abroad. One of her recent lecture on Body and Death: When I touch your Body with my Hands, was delivered in February 2009, at the American College of Greece. It was part of a Philosophical Seminar on Death and Metaphysics, and her research dealt with the depiction of death in the art of 20th-21st century Art.

    She has traveled extensively in Africa, Central Asia, Europe, North America and Mexico, as well as in India, where she lived for a number of years.

    She resides in Athens, Greece, where she paints and exhibits her work. She is publishing shortly a book on a deceased Greek artist Paschalis Haralampides. Apart from her research on Art History Aesthetics, she writes artistic fairytales, like Fairytales of the Brush, which will be published soon.

    She has a son and two lovely grandchildren, who live in London.

More Irony

Guardians Before God: The Sumerian Origins of Angels

Guardians Before God: The Sumerian Origins of Angels

Dr Hara's research on the winged messengers of Western faith starts with these wingless creatures guarding Sumerian doorways. This is the story of angels and how they learned to fly... When we think of angels, we conjure images refined by centuries of Christian art:...

RAMBLINGS #10 – Goodbye Mt. Parnassos, Hello War

RAMBLINGS #10 – Goodbye Mt. Parnassos, Hello War

A drive down from myth-haunted Mt. Parnassus into the passes, graveyards, and battlefields Picture Credits: Edward Dodwell, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons   It is said that Zeus, the great philanderer, lay with Mnemosyne (Memory), a Titan, for a marathon...

WORDS, WORDS, WORDS II: Inspiration

WORDS, WORDS, WORDS II: Inspiration

This is the second essay by Peter on the intricacies of the English language. Here, he writes on where inspiration comes from, and why no amount of effort can quite summon it. My first piece in the English language series talked about the quality of writing that...

The Last Puritan

The Last Puritan

Alexander Montgomery writes a fleeting, intimate glimpse of Glenn Gould, the genius and the strange solitude of his greatness. Glenn Gould’s sitting in Fran’s Deli, St. Clair East, and I sit here, watching him from the pub across the street. There he is, the bastard,...

The Awkward One: Rediscovering Mary Bennett

The Awkward One: Rediscovering Mary Bennett

About the most forgettable Bennet sister and a retelling of Pride and Prejudice... “There are few people whom I really love, and still fewer of whom I think well. The more I see of the world, the more am I dissatisfied with it; and every day confirms my belief of the...

The Little Tanagra: Part 2

The Little Tanagra: Part 2

Previously in Part 1, Hara writes about young Arsinoe growing into a woman of remarkable talents at the sanctuary of Artemis at Brauron. But longing for freedom, she begins to plan her escape.     Arsinoe took longer each day to return from her...

The Little Tanagra: Part 1

The Little Tanagra: Part 1

We are delighted to introduce a new serialized work of literary fiction from Dr. Hara Papatheodorou: a fairy tale that reimagines the origins of the celebrated Tanagra figurines in ancient Greece.   In the small village of Tanagra, in Boeotia, there lived a poor...

Words, Words, Words

Words, Words, Words

Starting in April 2026, The Ironist is starting a running monthly series of articles on the English language written by our very own contributor Peter Scotchmer, a retired English teacher. Polonius: ‘What is the matter you read, my lord?’ Hamlet: ‘Words, words,...

Skinny Legs and All: The Seriousness of the Absurd

Skinny Legs and All: The Seriousness of the Absurd

Talking objects, messy love, art, philosophy, and global conflict. All in one book. “In the haunted house of life, art is the only stair that doesn’t creak.” Over time I have come to believe that the higher the element of fantasy in a book, the more serious it often...