The Ironist

Differing Perspectives

RAMBLINGS #10 – Goodbye Mt. Parnassos, Hello War

A drive down from myth-haunted Mt. Parnassus into the passes, graveyards, and battlefields

Picture Credits: Edward Dodwell, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

 

It is said that Zeus, the great philanderer, lay with Mnemosyne (Memory), a Titan, for a marathon nine-day, ‘sexathon’ on top of Mt. Parnassos. The Titans were colossal, and this romp must have been exhausting. In due course, she bore nine daughters – the Muses. These daughters were the goddesses of literature, science, and the arts, representing divine creativity. When you invoke them, they whisper inspiration in your ears. The Greeks integrated memory with history and cultural identity. Poets and orators combined education with the power of imagination.

Mt. Parnassos is not only massive, but it seemed to become magical and mythic as I drove around it. Some think the name itself comes from the Luwians, the shadowy antecedents of the Trojans. Zeus was purported to have declared it the centre of the world. Such was its imaginative power that students in the 17th century called part of the Left Bank in Paris ‘Montparnasse.’ 

The Greeks believed that imagination, tradition and analysis should play a large part in their lives. Today we may have too many ephemeral thirty-second reels and social media posts, rendering our culture excessively banal and eliminating the need for thinking. There is a tendency to regard only the ‘new’ as worthwhile. Too many seek instant gratification and too few seek self-reflection.

In contrast, the contemporary audience of Aeschylus’ Oresteia would have known the story of Agamemnon’s murder by his wife Clytemnestra. In that story of the wooden horse, the priests said Agamemnon had to sacrifice his daughter Iphigeneia before he could sail for Troy. Such an act raises the moral imperative – can you kill your own daughter for a greater purpose? The audience weighs the culpability of Agamemnon, who had to choose between differing requirements – those of kingship, family, religion, moral and personal pride. Agamemnon was damned no matter what action he took. Ironically, the great king had become a pawn. 

All the characters in the play endure the consequences of their actions; even the innocent suffer. Like life itself, there is a universality to the inevitability of submitting to forces beyond our control. Iphigeina, whose name ironically means “Strongly-Born,” obediently submits to her sacrifice at Aulis, her warm blood running over the cold stone of the altar. Thus, imagination aids our understanding of the hard world around us. Even the ‘happy’ ending of the play offers no redemption – there is now ‘Law’, no longer merely ‘Vengeance’ – but the audience knows that there are inadequacies in the Law when a Tyrant rules… 

I drove down from Mt. Parnassos through the Brallos Pass with a profound sense that much of our modern world has lost the awareness of moral complexity. Things aren’t black and white. When we think, we see that most things have shades of grey – and that is what makes it hard for us to choose. And we are wiser for seeing the shades of grey.

There was a rising morning mist and a light rain falling that day. Intermittent views of soaring mountains and deep valleys appeared and disappeared in spectacular randomness. It felt as though nature was sentient; watching. The narrow road twisted, turned, rose, fell and swept down to the sea. I loved using the gears of my little Fiat, the engine singing as it worked up the inclines and braked bravely on the declines. It was fun – and the Muses had kindly cleared the road of traffic. 

In places I could see concrete footings of a future, bland, four-lane highway. I am sure there will be some great architectural, sweeping bridges. (In Europe, unlike so much of North America, they do spend money on good design). But it will be sad to see the two-lane road gone. Is life worth living if we have everything simplified for us? 

Or is it that, perhaps,many want an anaesthetized life? Surely the ruling class prefers a less demanding electorate? Maybe this is why we get the governments we deserve. Continuing that idea, perhaps boring lives lead to the popularity of extreme sports? Possibly we are coddled to avoid challenges. Why exert or learn if a handheld AI-controlled telephone provides the answers? Is there a danger we could become the Eloi of H.G. Wells’ Time Machine? The Eloi lived a life without cares, but were raised to be eaten by the Morlocks. If so, what a future we have.

Certainly, as the little engine in my Fiat struggled on inclines, I had to double de-clutch and heel-and-toe to try and maintain a constant speed. These days, most cars are automatics, and the fun of a manual transmission has been lost. No ‘virtual’ computer game is as thrilling as go-karting in an empty parking lot…our lives are indeed drugged with gimmicks of induced indolence.

I stopped in Brallos. Exactly 85 years ago to the day in 1941, Australian and New Zealand battalions fought a fighting retreat here from advancing Germans. Back then, trucks had no synchromesh and no air conditioning – let alone power brakes and steering. I felt for the farmers from the flatlands Down Under who had to fight the German mountain battalion that had trained in the Austrian Alps.  

A military cemetery caught my attention – but it was from another war. In WWI, the 49th Stationary Hospital was established beneath Mt. Parnassos for soldiers of the Gallipoli campaign. It had an impressive view of the mountains, and was quiet and beautifully maintained. Many graves were from 1919. Perhaps some of the patients lingered here with war injuries before being carried off by influenza. How far from home they are buried. Seven were from the Labour Corp, Russians continuing to fight for the Allies after the Bolsheviks pulled out of the war. I was touched by Sapper R.H. Gibbons’ epitaph: “A noble death. Far from friends and family. Death divides but memories cling.” I wonder if those were his thoughts as he slipped away. It was tragic. Imagine losing a son or father. The loss for those people is no less from being so long ago. 

I think for many of us the years have allowed us to reconsider the irrecoverable cost of WWI. The mindless wastage of young lives. Do we really need to fight so many wars? Have you noticed that the proponents of war avoid discussing the cost of a war?

It is only twenty miles to one of the most famous battlefields in recorded history – the stand of King Leonidas and his Spartans, Thespians and Thebans against the Persians at Thermopylae. Greatly outnumbered, the Greeks fought to the death, hacked by swords and skewered with arrows. The Persian King of Kings, Xerxes the Great, was a megalomaniac who had famously lashed, branded and shackled the sea after his pontoon bridge across the Hellespont had been destroyed in a storm. That was a delightfully extravagant act of hubris.

Although it may seem these battles and wars are far away and long ago, new wars loom over us now. As Wilfred Owen says of Horace’s Ode, ‘the eternal lie’ is yet repeated, dulce et decorum est pro patri mori (it is noble and just to die on behalf of your native land). We need to remember the cost of war, to analyze the consequences, employing our imagination and our memory. Most of the time, wars are fought for greed, and achieve nothing – except death and destruction.

49th Stationary Hospital at Brallos, Phthiotis, Greece, 1919. Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0). Source: Wellcome

Contributed by

Nigel Scotchmer

Author

  • Nigel Scotchmer

    Nigel’s peripatetic path in life gives him, he believes, a unique perspective on the world around him. He has worked at many occupations over the years from driving a truck, writing welding standards, to being an international salesman,\ accountant and business owner. Brought up in a family that believed that Antigone in the Greek myth was correct to stand up and die for her belief that fairness and truth were more important than the ranting raves of the unthinking mob – his father accepted the consequences of refusing to fire a homosexual in the 1950s – Nigel believes irony is the greatest tool for both encouraging equity and our enjoyment of life. Since irony involves the interplay between emotions, reality and chance, its appreciation can provide meaning to the often inexplicable world in which we live. He said, when interviewed for this summary: “No, we can’t all be heroes, and too often we make the wrong choice, for the wrong reasons – but at least irony can bring peace to us by helping reconcile the warring elements.”

    Nigel loves literature – especially books and poems that deal with universal themes such as love, war, and justice – and is now happily retired from the world of business. Ironically, (like countless retirees before him!), he says he has the ambition to be a great writer and is currently writing fiction full-time….

    Visit him at https://nigelscotchmer.com/

More Irony

Inspiration

Inspiration

This is the second essay by Peter on the intricacies of the English language. Here, he writes on where inspiration comes from, and why no amount of effort can quite summon it. My first piece in the English language series talked about the quality of writing that...

The Last Puritan

The Last Puritan

Alexander Montgomery writes a fleeting, intimate glimpse of Glenn Gould, the genius and the strange solitude of his greatness. Glenn Gould’s sitting in Fran’s Deli, St. Clair East, and I sit here, watching him from the pub across the street. There he is, the bastard,...

The Awkward One: Rediscovering Mary Bennett

The Awkward One: Rediscovering Mary Bennett

About the most forgettable Bennet sister and a retelling of Pride and Prejudice... “There are few people whom I really love, and still fewer of whom I think well. The more I see of the world, the more am I dissatisfied with it; and every day confirms my belief of the...

The Little Tanagra: Part 2

The Little Tanagra: Part 2

Previously in Part 1, Hara writes about young Arsinoe growing into a woman of remarkable talents at the sanctuary of Artemis at Brauron. But longing for freedom, she begins to plan her escape.     Arsinoe took longer each day to return from her...

The Little Tanagra: Part 1

The Little Tanagra: Part 1

We are delighted to introduce a new serialized work of literary fiction from Dr. Hara Papatheodorou: a fairy tale that reimagines the origins of the celebrated Tanagra figurines in ancient Greece.   In the small village of Tanagra, in Boeotia, there lived a poor...

Starting in April 2026, The Ironist is starting a running monthly series of articles on the English language written by our very own contributor Peter Scotchmer, a retired English teacher. Polonius: ‘What is the matter you read, my lord?’ Hamlet: ‘Words, words,...

Skinny Legs and All: The Seriousness of the Absurd

Skinny Legs and All: The Seriousness of the Absurd

Talking objects, messy love, art, philosophy, and global conflict. All in one book. “In the haunted house of life, art is the only stair that doesn’t creak.” Over time I have come to believe that the higher the element of fantasy in a book, the more serious it often...

Utopian Delusions

Utopian Delusions

Peter Scotchmer writes about the enduring lure of utopia and why humanity’s attempts to build perfect societies so often end in dystopia.   I will not walk with your progressive apes, Erect and sapient. Before them gapes The dark abyss to which their progress...

Forgotten Heroes #8 – Pauolos Paella the Peacemaker

Forgotten Heroes #8 – Pauolos Paella the Peacemaker

In this Forgotten Heroes story, Alfred Russel Wallace, flying whales called linanders, and a peace-making dish collide in an improbable history of the world’s most famous rice pan.   Recently discovered petroglyph of a linander assisting ancient boy scouts...